David Barton Plays ‘Expert’ Again

by

David Barton clearly has no shame. Once again he’s letting the far-right Web site OneNewsNow — “a Christian news service . . . that exists to present the day’s stories from a biblical perspective” — promote him as an authority on the Constitution. Last summer OneNewsNow quoted the head of the far-right organization WallBuilders as a “constitutional expert” explaining why proposed congressional health insurance reform bills were supposedly unconstitutional. Today the outfit revisits the issue and quotes “constitutional historian” David Barton claiming that the health reform bills would fail to pass court challenges:

“I think there’s huge constitutional problems with this thing, and it may be that we see the power of Congress limited constitutionally through a number of different venues by these various lawsuits that are out there.”

The far right’s contempt for real expertise becomes clearer every day. Barton is no more a “constitutional historian” than George Clooney is a medical expert because he played a doctor on television. In reality, Barton is just a smooth-talking political propagandist who collects historical memorabilia and plays fast and loose with facts. He has zero academic credentials to back up a claim to being any kind of history “expert” — in fact, his bachelor’s degree is in religious education, not history at all. He’s the author of a string of self-published books promoting his political ideology, but he is not employed as a historian by a university or research institution, and he does not submit his work to review by real academics who actually study and understand history.

It was bad enough that the State Board of Education put Barton on a panel of so-called “experts” helping revise social studies curriculum standards for Texas public schools. Now OneNewsNow is simply perpetuating this fraud on a broader audience.

4 Responses to “David Barton Plays ‘Expert’ Again”

  1. jdg Says:

    It’s so sad that Johnathan Saenz from FMF thinks that you guys are behind this Barton persona. It’s also fun to debate Saenz; he’s clueless.

  2. Charles Says:

    “I think there’s huge constitutional problems with this thing, and it may be that we see the power of Congress limited constitutionally through a number of different venues by these various lawsuits that are out there.”

    With statements like that on his vita, I sure hope he never claims to be an expert in constitutional law. The President of the United States is a bonafide expert in constitutional law, and I suspect that he and his fellow Democrats in Congress (many of whom are also lawyers) have this issue cornered legally with regard to the health care bill. This Republican lawsuit business is a cheap public relations stunt designed to keep the wingnut faithful from running them out of town on a rail for their 60-40 failure. “Well guys, we tried!!!!” (Chuckle)

  3. Marsha C. Elgin Says:

    “…there’s … problems…”

    He’s not even qualified to be an authority on grammar.

  4. David Washburn Says:

    As McElroy has indicated by direct statement, and the other Creationists on the SBOE by their actions, the religious right has contempt for real expertise, if it fails to support their political agenda.

    The anti-intellectualism of Fundamentalist Christianity has not changed much since the days of William Jennings Bryan, except that it is a little stealthier. Bryan was honest enough to say he got all his information from the KJV Bible and made fun of those with secular “book learning.” Today they know that the academic expert label has some political utility and some are not above pretending to be one if it gives them a soapbox.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: